| 2021 Phil Steele FCS All-America Teams |
| OFFENSE |
|
1st TEAM |
2nd TEAM |
3rd TEAM |
4th TEAM |
| QB |
Cole Kelley, Southeastern Louisiana, Sr. |
Eric Barriere, Eastern Washington, Sr. |
Cole Johnson, James Madison, Sr. |
Cameron Ward, UIW, Soph. |
| RB |
Pierre Strong Jr., South Dakota St, Sr. |
Isaiah Ifanse, Montana St, Jr. |
Jaleel McLaughlin, Youngstown St, Jr. |
Darius Hale, Central Arkansas, Fr. |
| RB |
Quay Holmes, ETSU, Jr. |
Ramon Jefferson, Sam Houston, Jr. |
Geno Hess, Southeast Missouri, Sr. |
Malik Grant, Sacred Heart, Jr. |
| FB |
Hunter Luepke, North Dakota St, Jr. |
Logan Kendall, Idaho, Jr. |
Joe Kenny, Rhode Island, Sr. |
Coy Williams, Davidson, Sr. |
| WR |
Xavier Gipson, Stephen F. Austin, Soph. |
Taylor Grimes, UIW, Jr. |
BJ Byrd, Morehead St, Sr. |
Montrell Washington, Samford, Sr. |
| WR |
Dai'Jean Dixon, Nicholls, Sr. |
Talolo Limu-Jones, Eastern Washington, Sr. |
Austin Mitchell, SLU, Sr. |
Antwane Wells Jr., James Madison, Fr. |
| WR |
Tyler Hudson, Central Arkansas, Soph. |
Dennis Houston, Western Illinois, Sr. |
Christian Watson, North Dakota St, Sr. |
Jalyn Witcher, Presbyterian, Fr. |
| TE |
Tucker Kraft, South Dakota St, Soph. |
Kemari Averett, Bethune-Cookman, Sr. |
Ryan Miller, Furman, Sr. |
Marshel Martin, Sacramento St, Soph. |
| OL |
Trevor Penning, Northern Iowa, Sr. |
Cordell Volson, North Dakota St, Sr. |
Matthan Hatchie, UT Martin, Jr. |
Andrew Trainer, William & Mary, Sr. |
| OL |
Cole Strange, Chattanooga, Sr. |
Lewis Kidd, Montana St, Sr. |
Hunter Nourzad, Cornell, Sr. |
AJ Farris, Monmouth, Sr. |
| OL |
Nick Zakelj, Fordham, Sr. |
P.J. Burkhalter, Nicholls, Sr. |
Tristen Taylor, Eastern Washington, Sr. |
Justin Redd, Norfolk St, Jr. |
| OL |
Braxton Jones, Southern Utah, Jr. |
Tre'mond Shorts, ETSU, Jr. |
Prince Pines, Sam Houston, Soph. |
ZeVeyon Furcron, Southern Illinois, Sr. |
| OL |
Matt Waletzko, North Dakota, Sr. |
David Kroll, Delaware, Sr. |
Michael Corbi, Villanova, Sr. |
Ja'Tyre Carter, Southern, Sr. |
| DEFENSE |
|
1st TEAM |
2nd TEAM |
3rd TEAM |
4th TEAM |
| DL |
Bryce Carter, James Madison, Sr. |
James Houston, Jackson St, Sr. |
Josiah Erickson, Sacramento St, Sr. |
Brayden Thomas, North Dakota St, Sr. |
| DL |
Jared Brinkman, Northern Iowa, Sr. |
Nate Lynn, William & Mary, Soph. |
Brevin Allen, Campbell, Sr. |
Rayshad Nichols, Stephen F. Austin, Sr. |
| DL |
Devonnsha Maxwell, Chattanooga, Jr. |
Isaiah Chambers, McNeese, Sr. |
Josiah Silver, New Hampshire, Fr. |
Jahari Kay, Sam Houston, Sr. |
| DL |
Daniel Hardy, Montana St, Sr. |
Vaughn Taylor Jr., Morehead St, Sr. |
Titus Leo, Wagner, Sr. |
Shaundre Mims, Charleston Southern, Sr. |
| LB |
Troy Andersen, Montana St, Sr. |
Jacob Dobbs, Holy Cross, Jr. |
Tylar Wiltz, Missouri St, Jr. |
Jeremiah Tyler, Princeton, Sr. |
| LB |
Isaiah Land, Florida A&M, Jr. |
Stone Snyder, VMI, Jr. |
Tre Walker, Idaho, Sr. |
Tristan Wheeler, Richmond, Soph. |
| LB |
Forrest Rhyne, Villanova, Sr. |
Jared Folks, ETSU, Sr. |
Jack Cochrane, South Dakota, Sr. |
David Hoage, Northern Colorado, Soph. |
| LB |
Patrick O'Connell, Montana, Jr. |
Adam Bock, South Dakota St, Soph. |
Kelechi Anyalebechi, UIW, Sr. |
Diamonte Tucker-Dorsey, James Madison, Jr. |
| DB |
Decobie Durant, South Carolina St, Sr. |
Zyon McCollum, Sam Houston, Sr. |
Montrae Braswell, Missouri St, Soph. |
Qua Brown, Southern Illinois, Sr. |
| DB |
Justin Ford, Montana, Sr. |
Greg Ross, James Madison, Sr. |
Darius Joiner, Western Illinois, Sr. |
Davion Ross, Eastern Kentucky, Soph. |
| DB |
Christian Benford, Villanova, Sr. |
Devin Hafford, Tarleton St, Sr. |
Johnathon Edwards, Austin Peay, Sr. |
Zy Alexander, Southeastern Louisiana, Fr. |
| DB |
Markquese Bell, Florida A&M, Sr. |
Koby Perry, Austin Peay, Sr. |
Tyree Robinson, ETSU, Sr. |
K.J. Smith, North Alabama, Sr. |
| SPECIAL TEAMS |
|
1st TEAM |
2nd TEAM |
3rd TEAM |
4th TEAM |
| K |
Ethan Ratke, James Madison, Sr. |
Matt Cook, UNI, Soph. |
Jose Pizano, Missouri St, Soph. |
Kyle Sentowski, Sacramento St, Jr. |
| P |
Brian Buschini, Montana, Fr. |
Daniel Whelan, UC Davis, Sr. |
Grant Burkett, Missouri St, Fr. |
Max Quick, Stephen F. Austin, Soph. |
| KR |
Isaiah Bolden, Jackson St, Jr. |
Malik Flowers, Montana, Jr. |
Rashid Shaheed, Weber St, Sr. |
Calvin Jones, Western Carolina, Fr. |
| PR |
Warren Newman, Jackson St, Sr. |
Jah-Marae Sheread, Florida A&M, Jr. |
Montrell Washington, Samford, Sr. |
Jayden Price, North Dakota St, Jr. |
| AP |
Montrell Washington, Samford, Sr. |
Rashid Shaheed, Weber St, Sr. |
Xavier Gipson, Stephen F. Austin, Soph. |
Jacob Saylors, ETSU, Jr. |
| LS |
Matthew O'Donoghue, Montana, Sr. |
Kyle Davis, James Madison, Jr. |
Robert Soderholm, VMI, Sr. |
Dalton Godfrey, South Dakota, Jr. |
|
| 2021 FCS OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: QB Cole Kelley, Southeastern Louisiana, Sr. |
|
| 2021 FCS DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: LB Patrick O'Connell, Montana, Jr. |
| 2021 FCS OFFENSIVE LINEMAN OF THE YEAR: OT Trevor Penning, Northern Iowa, Sr. |
| 2021 FCS FRESHMAN OF THE YEAR: QB Shedeur Sanders, Jackson St |
